Podcast: Play in new window | Download
This is episode 500 of the Superfast Recruitment podcast. When I say that out loud, it still surprises me a little.
Thirteen years ago I had an idea. We work with recruitment businesses every day, we understand their world, and there is so much we could share that would genuinely help them. What if we did a podcast?
That was the idea. But an idea on its own is nothing. What made 500 episodes happen is that we built a system around it. A process, a schedule, a commitment to showing up every single week, whether we felt inspired or not, whether the market was busy or quiet, whether it felt like anyone was listening or not.
And the reason I am sharing that is because this post is about exactly that. The gap between having an idea and making it happen. Between knowing you should be doing something with your recruitment marketing and building a system that means it gets done.
If you have been around a while, you will know that is a topic close to my heart.
The Recruitment Marketing Problem Most Business Owners Won’t Admit
Let me tell you about a conversation I had recently with a recruitment business owner. We will call her Emma.
Emma runs a six-person agency specialising in manufacturing recruitment. Brilliant at her job. Knows her market inside out. But when we got on our call, she pulled up her notes app and showed me her marketing to-do list.
Eight items. Start posting regularly on LinkedIn. Get some client testimonials. Update the website content. Send emails to the database. Maybe do some case studies. Create a downloadable guide. Be more visible. Do something about personal branding.
And do you know how many of those eight things she had done? None. Well, one half-done website content update that never got finished.
When I asked her which of those eight things she should do first, she said: “I honestly don’t know. That’s the problem. I know I need to do something, but I don’t know where to start, and I definitely don’t know how to make it stick.”
She was not drowning in ideas. She was stuck between knowing she needed to market better and having no clear plan to do it. And if I am honest, she is not alone. This is the conversation we have with eight out of ten recruitment business owners.
I call this the Implementation Gap.
Why Recruitment Business Owners Struggle to Turn Marketing Ideas into Action
Here is what I have learned after eighteen years working exclusively with recruitment businesses: the problem is rarely a lack of ideas. Most of you have plenty. The problem is that those ideas never get turned into action. They stay as vague intentions.
“I should be more active on LinkedIn.” “I need to do something with my database.” “We should probably have better content on the website.” “I know I should be asking for testimonials.”
And there is something else worth saying here. A lot of the ideas recruitment business owners pick up are not right for them. You are reading general business content, seeing what big brands do, or trying to copy what a competitor seems to be doing. Much of it simply does not translate. It is not built for a six or eight person recruitment firm trying to win retained clients in a niche sector. So you end up pursuing things that are disjointed, hard to sustain at your size, or just not the right fit for where you are right now. That is not a motivation problem. That is a starting-point problem.
So before we even get to implementation, the gap has three parts. You do not know which thing to do first, everything feels equally important and equally overwhelming. Even when you pick something, you do not know how to turn it into a sustainable system. And you try to figure all of this out on your own, while running a business, and it just does not happen.
To close that gap, you need three things: clarity on what matters for a recruitment business your size and what order to do it in, a system that makes it sustainable rather than just possible, and support and accountability when things get hard or busy.
Without those three things, even your best intentions will fail. Not because you are not capable, but because you are trying to do something genuinely difficult, on your own, without a roadmap built for you.
5 Reasons Recruitment Marketing Dies Before It Even Starts
- The idea is too vague and there is no clear first step
Take “I should be more active on LinkedIn” as an example. What does that mean? Post daily? Three times a week? What topics? Long-form or quick insights?
“Be more active on LinkedIn” is not a plan. It is a vague intention. What you need is something like: “I am going to post twice a week on Tuesdays and Thursdays about the hiring challenges my clients face. I will write three posts on Monday evening and schedule them. I will do this for three months and track connection requests.” That is specific. That is doable. That has a system. But most recruitment business owners never get to that level of clarity.
- You do not know what to prioritise
You have a list of things you think you should be doing LinkedIn, website content, email campaigns, case studies, testimonials, networking, maybe video. But which one matters most? Which one will move your business forward?
Without a clear framework, you either try to do everything at once and get overwhelmed, or you pick the wrong thing and spend three months on something that does not generate a single lead. Guessing while you are time-poor is a recipe for wasted effort.
- You have underestimated the time and skill required
“Right, I am going to create video content.” Brilliant, video works. But between scripting, lighting, editing, captions and posting consistently, your first video will take three hours minimum. People see the polished one-minute result on LinkedIn. They do not see the three hours of work behind it. So they try it once, realise how long it takes, and never do it again.
- There is no system to sustain it
This is the killer. You might start something and even be consistent for a few weeks. But if there is no repeatable process, it falls apart the moment life gets busy.
Let’s say you decide to send a monthly email to your database. But where is the content coming from? Who is writing it? When? What happens if billing is mental and you just do not have time? Without a system, it relies entirely on you having time and mental energy every single month. One missed month becomes two. Two becomes three. And before you know it, you have not sent anything in six months.
- You are trying to figure it out alone
You are a recruitment expert. But marketing is not your expertise. So you are Googling “how to write LinkedIn posts,” second-guessing every piece of content, and making a hundred micro-decisions every time you try to do anything.
There is no one to tell you: that idea is a distraction, focus here instead. Or: this is good enough, just publish it. Or: here is the proven structure, just follow this. All of that takes enormous mental energy you simply do not have when you are running a business.
4 Questions to Ask Before You Implement Any Recruitment Marketing Activity
Does this solve a problem I have right now?
Not a problem you might have one day. Not a problem your competitor has. A problem you have right now. If you want to redesign your website, ask yourself why. Is your current website actively losing you business, or do you just think it looks a bit tired? If the real problem is that you are not getting enough leads, a new website probably will not solve it. Be honest about what problem you are trying to solve.
Do I have the resources to sustain this, not just start it?
Starting is easy. Sustaining is hard. If you are going to launch a newsletter, can you commit to sending it every month for twelve months? Not just the first three. If the answer is no, do not start. Build the system that makes the answer yes.
What am I prepared to stop doing to make room for this?
Every new thing you add means something else gets less attention. Your calendar is already full. Your to-do list is already overwhelming. Something has to give. Decide what that is before you start, or the new activity will quietly die within weeks.
Is this going to generate leads and billings, or just make me look busy?
Be brutally honest. Is this activity going to bring candidates or clients closer to you, or is it just visible activity that makes you feel productive? You can test an idea small before going all in: a handful of videos, a modest ad budget. Data helps you decide whether something is worth continuing without wasting months finding out. Activity is not the same as progress.
How to Actually Implement Recruitment Marketing That Sticks
Step one: define what done looks like
Get specific. Not “improve our LinkedIn presence”, for example: “Post twice a week for the next three months. Track connection requests and inbound messages. Review data at 90 days.” Not “send more emails to our database”, for example: “Send a monthly email on the first Wednesday of every month. Include one client insight, one candidate tip and one relevant industry update.” You need to know exactly what success looks like and when you will evaluate whether it is working.
Step two: identify the smallest possible first action
What is the very first thing you need to do? Not the whole project. Just the first step. If you want to create case studies, that first step is emailing three clients this week asking if they would be willing to chat. That is it. The mistake is looking at the whole mountain. “I need to create case studies” feels overwhelming. “I need to email three people” is doable.
Step three: build the system around it
How are you going to make this repeatable? If it is LinkedIn posts: when will you write them, where will you store ideas, how will you batch them? If it is a monthly newsletter: what is the content structure, what is the deadline, who reviews it before it goes out? The system is what keeps things going when motivation fades. And the system needs to be realistic, one that works with your actual life, not your ideal life.
Step four: get accountability
Tell someone what you are doing and when you will have it done. Your business partner, your team, a mentor, a membership group. One of our Superfast Circle members told me recently: “I show up to the group calls because I don’t want to be the person who said they’d do something and didn’t. That accountability has kept me going more than motivation ever did.” That is the truth of it. Accountability works when motivation does not.
Step five: review and adjust
Set a checkpoint at thirty, sixty and ninety days. Look at the data. What is working? What is not? Maybe you realise three LinkedIn posts a week is too much. Drop to two. Two consistent posts are infinitely better than three inconsistent ones. Review, adjust and keep going.
Thanks
Denise
How We Can Help You Close the Implementation Gap
Superfast Circle gives recruitment business owners the clarity, content resources and accountability to make marketing happen. Everything is built specifically for the recruitment and search sector, so you are never starting from scratch or guessing what to do next.
If you would like to find out more, book a call with us at superfastrecruitment.co.uk/call.
